Health care reform debate punctuated by misinformation

BY STEPHEN HEMELT
DAILY IBERIAN CITY EDITOR
Published/Last Modified on Monday, August 24, 2009 2:07 PM CDT

Whether it’s propaganda put on by the old guard insurance industry or a defense tactic formulated by ultra-conservative broadcasters, the misinformation put out about national health care reform is equal parts comical as it is disheartening.

The result is citizens from across the country and right here in Acadiana expressing their fears about such topics as death panels, a slippery slope toward socialism and rushed Washington reform.

None of those things are true. Like any president before him, President Barack Obama wants his domestic agenda to pass and be supported by a majority of Americans. With that in mind, it would be impossible to sponsor any legislation that has anything remotely tied to a “death panel” or single provider system akin to socialism.

Advertisement
Yet at every major town hall, including last week’s event hosted by U.S. Sen. David Vitter, R-Metairie, residents are fearful Obama’s next move will have the government pull the plug on grandma.

Such a provision could never be true, if for nothing more than the fact that grandmas vote. It would be political suicide and universally ignorant to create a national system that supported such nonsense. Yet, from small town to small town and big city to big city, people are still expressing those fears.

Why? Maybe they are being supported by the group that stands to lose the most through national health care reform — insurance companies.

Wendell Potter, a former insurance company communications executive, told CNN the insurance industry deliberately spreads false information with the goal of disrupting the debate.

A CNN.com story about health care myths posted last week said the insurance industry hires public relations firms that create front groups to try to “destroy health care reform by using terms like ‘government takeover of the health care system’ or we are heading down a ‘slippery slope toward socialism’ or ‘we’re going to kill your grandpa’ because of these health care regulations,” said Potter, now a senior fellow at the Center for Media and Democracy, which calls itself a nonpartisan watchdog group on public relations spin.

The issue has gotten so twisted in some circles that at many town hall events, the false issue of preventing Obama’s Socialism takeover is being debated instead of the sad state of our current health care system.

The debate, at least in the South, centers not on the 40 million plus Americans sitting without health insurance or the shady insurance company henchmen who now stand in between the insured and proper medical care but on false socialism fears.

Instead of real talk, powerful opinion-makers have shaped the debate from what Americans deserve in health care.

During Vitter’s town hall meeting in Lafayette last week, a man who identified himself as a U.S. veteran thanked the senator for showing his morals and values in fighting health care reform. It’s hard to believe Louisiana’s junior senator has many morals and values to display thanks to his connection with a Washington escort service that has opened a window for porn star Stormy Daniels to consider running against him.

Vitter’s not displaying morals and values. He is simply towing the hard line his national party has adopted in its fight to stem Democratic momentum built up during the last election cycle.

Administration proposals call for creating a government-funded health insurance plan for people who otherwise lack coverage. The previous sentence has nothing to do with socialism, death panels or rushed legislation.

Whether you disagree with the premise or its possibility, make sure not to be a pawn in a Washington power broker sand box game that has been going on for decades.

The American people spoke loudly and decisively in electing their current leadership. Health care reform will be a result of that choice.

STEPHEN HEMELT is city editor of The Daily Iberian. He can be reached at stephen.hemelt@daily-iberian.com.

Comments

    Jan B. wrote on Sep 6, 2009 12:08 PM:

    " To L.L .Onjou Have you read HR3200(or either of the other 2 unnumbered house bills) or the senate bill. Unless you have, you do not know what you are arguing for or against. A lot of people(including the President) are commenting , giving inacurate information and making promises that can't be kept if any of these bill pass. I don't know what doctors you have talked to,but the ones I have discussed this issue with(all local) are all against these bills. "

    L.L. Onjou wrote on Sep 6, 2009 8:23 AM:

    " Foolishness. People arguing against health care have no idea that they're arguing for or against. Thanks to hate media, ignorant mobs and insurance company shills (who spend millions of $$$ to stop this beneficial reform) people are either scared or angry. Many against reform would be against anything the president proposed.
    Most U.S. doctors support this reform, because health care is a moral and economic issue. Americans deserve better than to be used as cash funnels for corporations until sickness makes us a burden on citizens and our families. "

    BAM wrote on Aug 26, 2009 1:13 PM:

    " Misinformation ? Check out berniegoldberg.com and read about how
    Dan Rather lied and created false documents about Bush. "

    Outraged wrote on Aug 26, 2009 10:44 AM:

    " Misinformed only applies when you don't agree with the MISINFORMED!!!! If you agreed with the people it would become "Well Informed People"!!!! "

    Outraged wrote on Aug 26, 2009 8:14 AM:

    " Mr Hemelt : It seems when people like Barack and yourself get a education at some LIBERAL institution you come away with the same BIAS??? You become infected with the ELITIST attitude that WE know better than the COMMON folk!!!! I believe the reason for this is the Institutions are crawling with LIBERAL professors who INFECT the students with their BIAS!!!! I don't mean to be disrespectful in my analogy but I believe BIG BROTHER is not the answer !!! You have your opinion and you are entitled to it,but you are wrong!!! Health Care is not a RIGHT!!! "

    Jan B wrote on Aug 25, 2009 8:00 PM:

    " A government run public obtion! The government has done such a good job running other things. They can't figure out how much in debt we are in. They were only off a mire 2 trilion dollars( trilion with a T) in their calculations of our debt over the next 10 years.( I heard it may be more) Do you truly want to let the government run anything. PS Mr. Hemelt I strongly suggest you read HR3200( just 1018 pages) before calling people misinformed. You might find that you are the one misinformed. "

    BAM wrote on Aug 25, 2009 3:42 PM:

    " It's not Health Care Reform anymore, it's
    now referred to as Health Insurance Reform. What ever phrase you want to use, it's government take-over. Now we
    are not even smart enough to make our own decisions about our health. I know your intent is to get reaction. At this rate
    you'll be at the Boston Globe before you
    know it. NOT ! "

    agree with hemelt wrote on Aug 25, 2009 2:48 PM:

    " I agree and commend you for having the courage to publicly take an unpopular stance. It's sickening the way this debate has been twisted.
    In case those trying to tie you to the stake haven't bothered to check the facts, this debate is NOT about government run health care. What was put forward was a government run public option... similar to the Medicare no one wants to be eradicated. And the AARP itself called the "death panel" allegations nonsense.
    Bravo, Stephen Hemelt. "

    jg wrote on Aug 25, 2009 2:47 PM:

    " and by the way, why is CNN his only source cited in the piece? That's thorough journalisim! "

    JG wrote on Aug 25, 2009 2:46 PM:

    " I hope Mr. Hemelt is collecting a paycheck from Charlie Melancon's office as it appears to be working directly for them. I feel sorry for this man as he is obviously too young and uninformed about how this healthcare system and our current one really work! Once he pays taxes for a few more years and sees his taxes get squandered and siphoned off to political cronies, he may change his tune. Let's fix the current system...not add on to a house of cards that is collapsing as we speak. "

    Stupid Is As Stupid Does wrote on Aug 25, 2009 2:40 PM:

    " Are you on Melancon's staff? No, maybe Pelosi's staff? I have it, you are secretly a member of the socialist party who has never opened a history book or listened to anything other than CNN (Clinton News Network). For someone whose title is City Editor, Mr. Hemelt is deplorably uninformed and to date has had very little good to say about anything or anyone expressing conservative views. This article may well be your swansong in New Iberia! This is conservative country! "

    Frank Rizzo wrote on Aug 25, 2009 12:24 PM:

    " The obvious question here is, did Hemelt read the bill before writing this opinion? Since he goes on to cite CNN and the bill is over 1000 pages long, the obvious answer is NO! However, he continues to write the article and thus is guilty of doing exactly what he is criticizing others for doing, putting out misinformation from the "ultra-liberal" broadcasters! "

    No blood for opium wrote on Aug 25, 2009 6:54 AM:

    " Hemelt blasts the insurance companies and "ultra-conservative broadcasters" for putting out misinformation, yet he goes on to site CNN, as though the information that they put out is creditable and unbiased.
    Another ridiculous aspect of this piece is that in an opinion entitled "Health Care Reform Debate Punctuated by Misinformation" somehow Senator Vitter's personal life gets brought up again.
    Since Steven went to great lengths to connect the healthcare debate to Senator Vitter's personal life, you would think that he would be talented enough to also connect John Edward's personal life as well, but I guess not. "

    Jan B wrote on Aug 25, 2009 12:14 AM:

    " I am not an insurance Co. or talk radio. I don't feel misinformed (unless the info from HR3200 is misinformation) David Vitters values and morals or lack of has nothing to do with my controlling my own healthcare and what I deem is appropriate care for myself and my family. End of life I will discuss with my doctor and my family. When the government can mandate everyone has to have insurance and what that insurance will cover and what is appropriate care, it sounds a lot like socialism to me. "

    donna wrote on Aug 24, 2009 8:55 PM:

    " I had stopped both NI and Lafayette papers becuase of all the one sided stories (most liberal). I can get that from CNN. I just began getting the NI paper again. Mistake! I really think you should read the bills in congress before you begin commenting on them. I know you did not read this bill! It is clear by your comments. Have you see the polls? People do not want this! "

    old as dirt wrote on Aug 24, 2009 8:12 PM:

    " take a ride over to KANE, pick up that misinformed democrat there and you two go riding off into democrat sunset...please. I'm surprised you even bring up the indiscretions of Mr Vitter after your heroes of the democratic party are expertss at it...ie Clinton...Ted Kennedy...et al. If all you can reference to is CNN then you certainly have no real true facts yourself. Get a life- somewhere else preferably. "

    What The Health Care Bill Actually Says. wrote on Aug 24, 2009 3:30 PM:

    " Readmissions-The Term means, in the case of an individual who is discharged from an applicable hospital, the admission of the individual to the same or another applicable hospital within a time period SPECIFIED by the Secretary from the date of such discharge-
    THE GOVERNMENT DECIDES-
    (1) What is an applicable (medical)Condition
    (2) Whom is allowed readmission into a Hospital
    (3) No Judicial review of decisions made.The Government is above the Courts.
    These are a few of the evaluations on the readmissions to hospitals .Hopefully this does not happen to you or your family memebers
    HR3200-Pages 284-288,Sec1151 "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment related to this story. Use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

•Comments must be approved by an editor or the publisher before appearing on the Web site but are not verified for accuracy nor have we verified the identity of any person supposedly posting an comment. Please consider this as you consider any statement made. A thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

• Please note your comments must attempt to follow basic rules of grammar and punctuation or they will not be posted. Do not use unfamiliar abbreviations or text-like short cuts, like ur for your. Please keep your tone civil. You can say someone's idea is stupid but you cannot say someone is stupid.

• Comments should deal with matters of public concern. Problems with private individuals or private companies are not likely to get posted.

• Questions or comments about items posted should be e-mailed to dailyiberian@bellsouth.net.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds


Contact Us

Subscribe
Vacation Hold
General Email

Mailing Address:
The Daily Iberian
P.O. Box 9290
New Iberia, LA
70562-9290

Street Address:
926 East Main St.
New Iberia, LA 70560

Phone:
(337) 365-6773

Fax:
(337)-367-9640

Inside Louisiana:
800-365-6773

Local Weather