Gas vs. salt?

BY HEATHER MILLER THE DAILY IBERIAN
Published/Last Modified on Monday, March 9, 2009 2:09 PM CDT

COTE BLANCHE ISLAND — A proposed $500 million natural gas storage facility is in its pre-planning stages here, and though completion is years away, residents and workers who could be affected by the site are raising a number of concerns.

Henry Gas Storage LLC, a subsidiary of Houston-based Ranger Gas, is in the federal pre-permitting process to construct four natural gas storage caverns, a 12-mile natural gas pipeline and a 26-mile brine disposal pipeline through Cote Blanche Bay.

The project could create 20 permanent jobs, 1,600 temporary construction jobs and millions of dollars in tax revenue and business sales. But the location of the facility also could jeopardize the jobs of more than 150 salt mine workers at the North American Salt Co. at Cote Blanche Island.

Workers for the North American Salt Co. enter an elevator recently, headed to begin their shift at the salt mine at Cote Blanche Island. The company is concerned about an underground natural gas storage site proposed near the mine. The storage site is sought by Henry Gas Storage LLC. Heather Miller / The Daily Iberian

Advertisement
“Our concern is the obvious one,” said mine manager Gord Bull. “There are 150 full-time employees underground dealing with a large body of explosives. There’s a lot of unknowns with this (project).”

Nowhere in the country does a functioning salt mine co-exist with a natural gas storage facility, said Mark Migues, a salt mine employee and union president of United Steel Workers, the salt mine’s union.

“We will not be able to exist next to a storage facility of that nature,” Migues said.

But Henry Gas CEO Michael McCall said those kinds of operations exist side-by-side in Germany, and said there will be complex analysis on how far apart the two facilities need to be from each other before the gas storage construction begins.

“Issues related to safety, which is the single most important issue of all, will be fully documented in our final filing for federal permits,” McCall said.

Once the company gets a federal permit from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, McCall will still have to get permits from the Army Corps of Engineers, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, as well as the state Department of Natural Resources.

North American Salt Co. has a 99-year lease on its salt mine operations at Cote Blanche Island that expires in 2061, said NASC employee and union Vice President Vincent Louviere. But the land next to the salt mines was set aside decades ago by the island owners to have a hydrocarbon storage site built — the same type of facility being proposed by Henry Gas.

Henry Gas has had two “scoping” meetings in Franklin to get input from the people who would be affected, but Migues and Louviere said many people were, and still are, unaware of the site proposal and the possible dangers associated with it.

“Because of the faults we have, hot ash, sandstone, all porous material, when they start pressuring up this gas, we don’t know what’s going to happen,” Louviere said. “It may leak into our work areas, which is not a good thing.”

The salt mine employees, 60 to 70 percent of whom reside in Iberia Parish, have been able to voice their concerns at the last meeting, but Migues said commercial fisherman, oyster fishers and others in the fishing industry have not been notified of the project.

The brine disposal pipeline, which in its current plans will fall a few miles inside of Iberia Parish waters, will be pumping 10,000 gallons per minute of pure salt solution into waters that are less than 10 miles southeast of Marsh Island and the Shell Keys National Wildlife Refuge. The brine will have little to no oxygen in it, which in turn could have a detrimental effect on the vegetation and marine life in those waters, Louviere said.

The amount of brine disposal planned is less than what some projects in the Gulf of Mexico have called for, McCall said, and said studies have shown brine can breed higher concentrations of shrimp.

Eric Richards, spokes-man for the Gulf Consevation Coalition, said the U.S. Department of Energy claims brine makes fish more prevalent, a claim that Richards called “hogwash.”

“You start tampering with the ecology and when you do that the balance changes,” Richards said. “Chances are you’re going to lose something of value.”

After Hurricane Katrina eroded a large part of one of Alabama’s barrier islands, Richards said Mobile Bay saw a higher level of salinity in its waters.

“They’ve lost virtually all their oyster beds this year,” Richards said.

Though oyster beds are not affected by higher salt levels, the higher salt concentration breeds more oyster drills, predatory snails that kill oysters, Richards said.

Tony Jurisich, vice president of Gulf Oysters IV Inc., spoke out publicly through the FERC Web site, and stated in a letter he is concerned about what the brine disposal will do to the oyster leases his company owns near the proposed pipeline.

“If this project causes the mortality that we think it will, our business will be greatly affected and it could cause many fisherman to be out of work,” Jurisich said in the letter.

Others, however, support the project and what it would do for energy independence and the local economy.

“I fully support the project ... I believe that with the technology available today, this project can be safely operated on the island along with the salt mine,” said Bill Sandefer, director of admissions for Tulane University’s business school.

Sandefer said he is not affiliated with the company, but has family in the New Iberia area and said the company would bring “much-needed industrial support to the area.”

The next step for the future project depends largely on whether the FERC will call for an environmental assessment, or an environmental impact statement.

An environmental assessment will review all elements of the environment for potential impact. If further study is called for, an environmental impact statement will be done, too, said a FERC spokeswoman Tamara Young-Allen.

“The whole point of natural gas storage is to help balance out natural gas production with the extreme swings in natural gas consumption,” McCall said. “It’s an exceptional location to connect with existing natural gas pipelines, and to provide a big boost in energy in the country.”

There is a public comment section on the FERC Web site, www.ferc.gov, which allows anyone with concerns to post their name and comment. The comments are located under the eLibrary, and the Henry Gas docket number to view the comments is PF08-28.

There will be several more public hearings advertised through the local media before the federal pre-filing process is complete, Young-Allen said.

Comments

    F. Cox wrote on Mar 20, 2009 4:24 PM:

    " I am curious as to why an admissions director would think this is a good idea. I would like to know what sort of engineering/geology credentials he brings to the table. I wonder if he would feel the same way if the storage facility were located near his home, church, or school. "

    Pop wrote on Mar 13, 2009 6:43 PM:

    " The issue here is the safety of
    the men who work in the mine.I happen to work at Cote Blanche for the past 15 years.I don't know if anyone remembers the tradegy at Jefferson Island but we as miners do, including some of the same men that now work at Cote Blanche! "

    just me... wrote on Mar 10, 2009 7:11 AM:

    " "Henry Gas CEO Michael McCall said those kinds of operations exist side-by-side in Germany."
    I think this is important. I don't understand...when the plant manager and the union president were interviewed, neither came forward with the information that the investment group that owns the Cote Blanche Mine is suddenly in danger of a hostile takeover...by a German company. "

    T. Smith wrote on Mar 9, 2009 4:55 PM:

    " If N.A. Salt wants to stop this development, they should either put up the money to buy out the storage option and the land or deal with the issues and evaluate the proposal without crying to the press and trying to drum up public opposition. They have been mining there long enough to offer proof of potential gas leaks and don't need to make unsubstantiated statements to the press. "

    Home Base wrote on Mar 9, 2009 3:19 PM:

    " The storage of natural gas in salt domes has nothing to do with energy independence. It's about market manipulation. "

    How wrote on Mar 9, 2009 2:19 PM:

    " This guy from Tulane said that the storage facility will bring much needed
    industry to the area -- In what way??
    they are saying to create 20 jobs -- we will loose 150. Where will the other 130 go??? What industry is being created,if it doesn't actively employ anyone??

    And in additon to the loss of the 150 jobs, what about the commerical fishing loss?? Sandefer and McCall don't live here and don't care. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment related to this story. Use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

•Comments must be approved by an editor or the publisher before appearing on the Web site but are not verified for accuracy nor have we verified the identity of any person supposedly posting an comment. Please consider this as you consider any statement made. A thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

• Please note your comments must attempt to follow basic rules of grammar and punctuation or they will not be posted. Do not use unfamiliar abbreviations or text-like short cuts, like ur for your. Please keep your tone civil. You can say someone's idea is stupid but you cannot say someone is stupid.

• Comments should deal with matters of public concern. Problems with private individuals or private companies are not likely to get posted.

• Questions or comments about items posted should be e-mailed to dailyiberian@bellsouth.net.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds


Contact Us

Subscribe
Vacation Hold
General Email

Mailing Address:
The Daily Iberian
P.O. Box 9290
New Iberia, LA
70562-9290

Street Address:
926 East Main St.
New Iberia, LA 70560

Phone:
(337) 365-6773

Fax:
(337)-367-9640

Inside Louisiana:
800-365-6773

Local Weather